23 Comments
User's avatar
Louise's avatar

I love panettone but am indifferent to pandoro. Growing up, Christmas Day breakfast for us was buttered toasted slices of panettone, and it is a source of great grief to me that my daughter is a pandoro person and refuses to continue the tradition. I love torrone, all sorts, and pan forte is my absolute favourite winter sweet. The best type of panettone to be gifted is one in a nice tin, which can be used year after year.

Gillian Longworth McGuire's avatar

I have such a tin collection now! (The tragedy of the bland pandoro choice 😭💔 I have been searching for that grappa soaked one that I bought last year with no luck 😔)

Lolly Martyn's avatar

Fantastic dive and details into all the regional goodies!!!

Michele Boyer's avatar

Love this! I cannot believe I never had panettone until my second year ('22) wintering in Italy. I thought that they were too big for just me. Uhhh, nope! Luckily, where I am in Melbourne I have a great Italian butcher who gets them in for the holidays. While it won't be the same as being there this festive season, it will help.

Gillian Longworth McGuire's avatar

It took me a long time to figure out they were delicious! Christmas in Melbourne sounds wonderful!

Life Lived Italian's avatar

An official Olympic panettone! At first, I thought you meant it would be an official sport of the Olympics in Milan, which seemed fair enough. At last, I thought, I'll get my medal.

Kaaren Sl's avatar

I always order more than I should from Corti Brothers in Sacramento, California. Guaranteed happiness!

Betty Carlson's avatar

We have a fishmonger here, of all things, who always imports a fabulous selection of panetonne for the holidays. I always indulge.

Riana | Teaspoon of Adventure's avatar

Ooo both sound delicious! We’ll be in Italy in late February. Any chance these will still be around or are they only available at Christmas?

Gillian Longworth McGuire's avatar

There may be a few stragglers. but. You will definitely find Carnevale sweets. In Venice we have fritelle (deep fried doughnut-like filled with ricotta or stuffed with raisins) I have a guide in my archives. In Rome there is frappe (strips of deep fried dough dusted with sugar) and castagnole (another doughnut adjacent treat)

Riana | Teaspoon of Adventure's avatar

Thank you! Those all sound delicious. I’ll keep an eye out!

Rick's avatar

I was on the Big Island of Hawaii for Christmas and there was a giant panettone Display in the supermarket! Buon Natale to me🎄

Gillian Longworth McGuire's avatar

Now that is the perfect combination! 🌴🇮🇹

Gabriela R. Proietti's avatar

There is something so comforting/Italian about the grocery store panettone display, mixed with the water bottles. A great list as well!!

Gillian Longworth McGuire's avatar

I just love it! (Thank you 🙏)

Jean Passanante's avatar

I love this survey of Italian Christmas cakes. My favorite pandoro is the Nuvola, from Pasticceria Ghigo in Torino. Light and tender and, as its name suggests, cloud-like.

Michele Boyer's avatar

Ahhhh one of my all-time favorites! I have waited on line to get that deliciousness and bought it as a gift for some new Torino friends who invited me for a holiday gathering last December. Everyone at the party was ooo-ing and ahhhh-ing reverently over the 'snowball'.

Gillian Longworth McGuire's avatar

I would love to try that!! I am woefully uneducated about Torinese cuisine

Michele Boyer's avatar

You would LOVE it. Ghigo was recommended to me two years ago by a Chef friend from Florence as a must visit. It turned out to be right around the corner from my apartment and the lines there on Christmas week are 50 or more people. Worth it.

Jean Passanante's avatar

It’s worth getting to know. How could anyone not love the city that brought us giandujia? And grissini?

Crystal King's avatar

I shudder to think how much they will be this year with the tariffs. In Eataly and at Formaggio in Boston, some of the best could run up to $60 in previous years. Average for good quality panettone and pandoro and pandoro was around $30-40 (with the cheapest in supermarkets around $20), but who knows what we're facing now. 😭

Gillian Longworth McGuire's avatar

I tried to do tariff research but couldn’t get any straightforward answers. I hope they snuck some shipments in before the worst 🙏🥹 Maybe this is the opportunity for American bakers to take on a project!